Hopein thePink

Support and community

Getting a second opinion

Asking for a second opinion is common and sensible. Good doctors expect it, and it can help you feel sure about the path ahead.

When a second opinion can help

  • You have been told about a serious condition or a major treatment.
  • The options are complex or the trade-offs feel finely balanced.
  • You still have symptoms and do not feel your concerns were heard.
  • You simply want more confidence before you go ahead.

How to ask

You do not have to give a reason, but if you would like to, you could say: "This is a big decision and I'd feel better hearing another view. Could you help me arrange that?" Most doctors will share your results and write a referral.

You can also return to your GP, who can write you a new referral to another specialist. For some conditions a GP may suggest a public clinic or a specialist with a particular focus.

What to bring

  • Copies of test results, scans and reports, or confirmation they have been sent.
  • A list of medicines.
  • Notes from your first appointment and the options you were given.
  • Your questions, written down.

If the opinions are different

Doctors sometimes agree on the facts but differ on what to do next. Ask each one to explain their reasoning. You can take both views back to your GP, who can help you compare them. In some cases a third view, or a team meeting about your care, can help.

Second opinions for mental health

The same idea applies to mental health care. If a counsellor or psychologist does not feel like the right fit, or a diagnosis does not match your experience, you can ask your GP about seeing someone else. Finding the right person is part of the process, not a failure.

Things to keep in mind

  • Ask whether waiting for a second opinion carries any risk.
  • Check the cost and whether a referral is needed.
  • You are allowed to return to your first doctor afterwards.

Our page on facing a big health decision has more on weighing up choices. This is general information only; talk to a qualified health professional about your own care.